|
|
VOICES OF PAIN &
VOICES OF HOPE
Book Reviews
Voices of Pain & Voices of Hope: Students Speak About Racism
by Jerome
Rabow
Order on

Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company;
ISBN:
0787298255
Our Price: $16.95
Praise for Voices of Pain & Voices
of Hope:
- Professor Jerome Rabow has put
together an extremely valuable book which demonstrates that, despite
much progress since the civil rights movement of the 1960s, racism in
its many guises is still alive. In addition to the convincing evidence
for the persistence of this long standing America dilemma, Voices of
Pain and Voices of Hope provides a method for dealing with the
problem. College courses in which students express their individual
experiences with racism both orally and in writing become the place
for meaningful dialogue in which real attitude change takes place. The
many quotations from students, give a convincing first-hand feel for the
problem as well as demonstrating the process of confrontation with
prejudicial attitudes in their living form. An impressive and
psychologically insightful work.
Louis Breger, Ph.D Professor of
Psychoanalytic Studies, Emeritus at California Institute of Technology,
founding president of the Institute of Contemporary Psychoanalysis,
author of Freud: Darkness in the Midst of Vision (Wiley & Sons,
2000)
- Rabow and his students have tackled to
topic of racial relations in a way that finally makes the disparities
between Whites and other ethnicities in American society self-evident.
This is the raw, emotional, human experience of racism, from the
perspective of both the oppressors and the oppressed (who, we learn, can
sometimes be one and the same). Through the experiences of his students,
Rabow elucidates the dominance of White culture in example after
example, until it becomes impossible to deny. Though scholarly and
academic, this work has the heart and soul that are missing from many
theoretically- or empirically-focused discussions of race. The end
result is a dispiriting, but ultimately hopeful perspective that calls
each of us to consider what being an American really means."
Terri D. Conley, Ph.D. Social
Science Research Council Fellow and Adjunct Assistant Professor of
Psychology, California State University, Northridge
- Voices of Pain and Voices of Hope
is required reading for anyone wanting to learn about contemporary
racism and how this form of domination is learned, practiced and comes
to have widespread and deep impacts in our society. Rabow communicates
and illustrates through the writings of their college students the
multiple dimensions and dynamics of racism in the lives of young people
and in their relationships with each other and with their elders. The
book creatively and effectively describes the experiences and feelings
of their college students about the meaning of race and racism in their
every-day-lives. Using a powerful metaphor of a paint brush and bucket
of white paint that is wielded for the most part by White Americans
readers are skillfully and engagingly taught about a topic that is all
too often ignored or dealt with in vague and otherwise confusing ways.
Based on how it has impacted me, I strongly recommend that you read
"Voices of Pan and Voices of Hope."
James Crowfoot, Ph.D, Professor
Emeritus of Natural Resources and Urban and Regional Planning and Dean
Emeritus of the School of Natural Resources and Environment, University
of Michigan at Ann Arbor and former President of Antioch College, Yellow
Springs, Ohio.
- This extremely perceptive book
succinctly illustrates how today's new racism undermines our talk about
tolerance, understanding and social justice. This book should be read by
students and the parents of students who wish to understand what growing
up in America is about. It is especially important for teachers at all
levels of our educational system.
Carole Donahue, Los Angeles
Unified School District Academic Mentor Coordinator
- The list of social critics and pundits
who claim to speak for students confronting racial and ethnic tensions
on college campuses grows longer each year, but there is nothing quite
so convincing as the voices of students themselves. Rabow's book
provides these students with a megaphone, and they use it to address the
complexity of issues that engage them -- thereby avoiding the cliches
that have so often rendered 'the debate about race on campus' stale and
sterile. This is, in contrast, a breath of fresh air.
Troy Duster, Professor, New York
University.
- Voices is both street smart and
theoretically sophisticated. It allows the students to speak in their
own voices and their stories are often moving even to veterans like
myself. What they have to say resonates beyond the campus and demands to
be heard everywhere.
Howard J. Ehrlich, Director, The
Prejudice Institute and Editor of Perspectives: The newsletter of
prejudice, ethnoviolence and social policy.
- This book conclusively refutes the
notion that racism is dead. Brilliantly probing racial matters, Jerome
Rabow examines accounts from college student journals. White, Black,
Asian, Latino, Indian, and multiracial students grapple with the
realities of racial oppression that many white Americans deny. Ever
painful, often profound, the accounts offer major insights about the
persisting tragedy of white racism. One senses here great pessimism, as
students of color document much painful discrimination by teachers,
clerks, and the police. But there is hope too, for in their journals
many students of all backgrounds show they have learned to respect
others and to work assertively for the elimination of racism.
Joe Feagin, Graduate Research
Professor, University of Florida, and author Racist America (Routledge,
2000)
- Voices of Pain.... belongs in
the public discourse on where this nation
is on issues affecting race and ethnicity. I am excited to see this
publication and would urge all Americans to read this work and ponder
its contents.
California State Assemblymember,
Jackie Goldberg
- Is the American "melting pot"
working? Is racism and prejudice on the wane? Not according to
Professor Rabow's students, who reveal in this provocative new book how
old ideas and attitudes about race and difference persist in our new
multi-cultural, multi-ethnic world.
Neal Goldberg, L.C.S.W. and
author
- "Voices offers compelling
evidence that should challenge those who believe that racist actions are
infrequent and only an annoyance. Professor Rabow, through the voices of
his students, demonstrates the high degree of regularity, the prevalence
and the pain of racism for children of color as well as the sense of
privilege that develops among whites. This book also shows that when the
pain is brought into the open and conflicts unfold, it then becomes
possible for resolutions to occur. This book should be read by all of us
who teach and care about the future of American race relations."
Morgan Hatch, Teacher, L.A.
Unified School District.
- "Voices of Pain and Voices of Hope
chronicles the experiences that University of California Los Angeles
students have with racism and prejudice and the pain it invokes. Racism
is alive and well in US society. Professor Rabow documents the process
in which students recognize that they are racist. All too often
individuals perceive the "other" as racist and do not consider the
"self" as racist. It is vital that this self-realization occurs so that
racial/ethnic differences can be embraced rather than shunned. The
transformation that students experienced in this course is a nascent
beginning. The challenge they confront is to go beyond the classroom
and affect change in the broader society. This book encapsulates the
hope that someday racial/ethnic differences will be embraced and
appreciated, that racism will be dead and that America will fulfill its
promise .of participation and hope for all.
Anthony Hernandez, Ph.D.
Associate Professor, Charter College of Education, California State
University Los Angeles
- "Voices of Pain and Voices of Hope
is a must-read text for students of race relations. A racial mosaic of
privilege and disadvantage, Rabow's students come alive before our very
eyes in this timely work. We hear their voices loud and clear. They
chronicle the pain engendered by continuing racial oppression in
America, but still manage to provide us with reasons to hope for a
better future."
Darnell M. Hunt, Ph.D.
Director, Center for African American Studies. Professor of Sociology,
University of California, Los Angeles. Author, O.J. Simpson Fact and
Fictions (Cambridge Press 1999)
- "When articulate college students dig
deeply into their experience of race and speak honestly about it, the
result is a revealing picture of the challenge of diversity in
America."
Rosabeth Moss Kanter, Harvard
Business School, best-selling author of Evolve! and World
Class.
- A literary documentary, Voices walks
the reader through the real life experiences of individuals who have
personally been affected by the racism that covertly exists in America
today. (Prof. Rabow challenges the old boys club, thereby breaking free
from his silent privilege and adding to the canon on diversity.) Having
participated in the class as an undergraduate student at UCLA, I was
reminded of the voices of my own journey and understanding of Privilege
and Oppression. Currently, I teach and work in the area of diversity and
I recognize the necessity of this book. It is a must read for all who
teach Race and who wish to have an impact on their students
understanding of the chasms that exist between races and ethnicities.
Honest, candid and real, the reader is exposed to the truths of the
voices of oppressed and privileged individuals.
Ani Karayan, PhD, Adjunct
Professor, Department of Psychology, Antioch University Los Angeles
- Jerome Rabow's Voices of Pain and
Voices of Hope; Students Speak About Racism. is an enormously
impressive work. It is an original and daring approach to understanding
the meaning of race among today's college students. At large
universities like UCLA and Berkeley the faculty for the most part "deal"
with simmering racial tensions and pain by ignoring them, hoping that it
will all just go away. Rabow in contrast puts the confrontation of our
feelings about race and racism at the core of his teaching, confronting
rather than avoiding resentments and insensitivities that students bring
with them to the Big U which, I fear, we as professors only exacerbate.
"Voices" is based on a series of quite special courses Rabow taught in
the past few years in which, in addition to the usual readings and
assignments, students kept journals of their reactions to and
reflections on the often very emotional in-class goings on. Race, gender
and sexual preference become intertwined in ways that many older
academics will find discomforting, reminding us that, above all, these
are the thoughts and feelings of individuals caught up in many
dimensions of trauma and conflict, but in America the racial dimension
is always paramount. I recommend this book to anyone concerned with the
growing racial divide in the United States; I especially recommend it to
those who do not see this growing divide.
David Lopez, Professor of
Sociology at UCLA.
- This book can be appreciated on two
levels. At one level, it is a record of a white male professor's
discovery of the pervasiveness of racism even decades after the civil
rights movement. At a second level, it is a collection of college
students' accounts of either surviving the pain of racism or coming to
realize the privileges they had never noticed. Many professors fear
direct and concrete debates on race in their classroom, but Professor
Rabow voluntarily chose a method of instruction that would expose and
interrogate the biases of himself and his students. "Voices of Pain"
emerged from this experience, and documents how prejudice continues to
operate in everyday life. It's a book you won't soon forget.
Laura L. Miller, Social
Scientist, RAND
- My recent work with outreach to middle
and high school students from
educationally disadvantaged schools and communities suggests that the
school environment directly impacts how we learn and succeed in life. A
simple "commitment to diversity" is insufficient for involving all
students in their education. This book points to the urgent need to
create an environment on our campuses that embraces differences rather
than tolerating them, an essential ingredient to teaching and learning.
Jane S. Permaul, Chief Operating
Officer,UCLA ,Outreach, Assistant Vice Chancellor Emeritus
- "Voices of Pain and Voices of Hope
is an insightful book about how college students learn about, experience
and struggle with racial prejudice. Based on the personal journals that
students kept as they took Rabow's course, the book is an excellent
answer to those who mistakenly argue that we are in a post-racist
society. Students in courses dealing with race and ethnic diversity will
easily identify with the material since it is based on the experiences
of their peers."
Fred L. Pincus, Co-Editor "Race
and Ethnic Conflict", 2nd Edition (Westview, 1999) and affiliated with
the University of Maryland Baltimore County
- This work represents an important
contribution to all of the voices that must be heard as we struggle with
issues of difference, conflict and change. This book is part text, part
classroom exercise and part life lesson. It is a necessary addition to
any personal reading list and any professional library.
Jorja Prover, Adjunct Professor,
UCLA Department of Social Welfare
- Dr. Rabow casts a light on the dark
side of cultural issues impacting therapy. The wounds of racism not only
help shape the individual's identity, these wounds also give rise to
deep emotions. Dr. Rabow demonstrates that it is not only important to
know the client's experiences of racism; it is imperative the clinician
be aware of his or her own prejudices which may affect the therapist's
perception of the client...and the client's perception of the therapist.
Carolyn J. Roberts, Ph.D. MFT
- Therapists, parents and students
should read this work. As a therapist, I found Dr. Rabow's research
valuable in reminding us that the road to self-acceptance is still
littered with the obstacles of racism. He brilliantly illustrates the
connection between self acceptance and acceptance of others, and paints
the destructive picture of both the false sense of superiority and
inferiority that racism imposes. The book illustrates how healing can
occur when diversity is not just tolerated but embraced.
Toby Salter, MA, MFT
- Voices of pain & Voices of Hope
is a highly readable and wonderful contribution to the large and growing
literature on race and racism in America. By exploring the journals of
college students from one of America's most multiethnic campuses, it
allows the reader to get an inside-out grasp of the depth, breadth and
power of racism as it is experienced in everyday life. While America
has certainly made great progress in confronting the dreadful scourge of
racial oppression, this book makes it painfully clear just how much
serious work still needs to be done. This is a very valuable book for
anyone interested in gaining insight into the complex, multifaceted and
subtle dynamics of race in American society.
Professor James Sidanius,
Professor of Psychology and Political Science, The University of
California, Los Angeles, author of Social Dominance: An Intergroup
Theory of Social Hierarchy and Oppression, Cambridge University
Press (2001)
- Professor Jerome Rabow takes on the
tough issues of racism in the university, exposing its many dimensions
in the lives of young people today. His approach to teaching is brave,
sensitive, and audacious. This book lets students speak of their own
experience, revealing to us as readers both their pain and their hope.
It is an inspiring work of pedagogy that further advances the dialogue
on race and racism in America. We all have a great deal to learn from
these voices.
Jill Stein, Director of
Sociology, Dept. of Sociology & Anthropology, Santa Barbara City College
- From the manuscript we find out that
all is not well in one of the nation's most ethnically diverse campuses.
Through these voices on the ground, we see that racism for this new
college generation is not so subtle and race is not so unimportant as
many would claim, even among UCLA students, who are selected for their
desire to attend a diverse campus and their purported greater intellect.
We learn that the incidents of intolerance that these students endured
can be deeply scarring and enduring. These issues, although central in
the life of many of our students, are probably unbeknownst to most
professors. If we had a way to formally train college professors as
educators, then I think this should become a required book. The book is
short and its presentational style makes it an easy read but the central
message is well driven and supported with engaging passages from the
students.
Eddie Telles, Professor of
Sociology, University of California Los Angeles
- VOICES OF PAIN, VOICES OF HOPE
explores our struggles with racism in a vital way: from the inside out.
This book teaches that the social psychology of racism is based, above
all, on fear and vulnerability. Racism can be challenged in important
ways by facing up to the shameful privilege it defends and the inner
pain it masks. Rabow's students can be our teachers. This book will make
a valuable contribution to courses in sociology, psychology, education,
and ethnic studies.
Howard Winant, University of
California, Santa Barbara, author of
THE WORLD IS A GHETTO
|